It is not by accident that penal substitution has gained such prominence in Protestant Christianity. It has succeeded in systematizing the deception (Eph. 4:14) that God’s penal justice could actually somehow bring salvation, while it completely suppressed the voice of God’s premial justice that constitutes the authentic golden thread of divine salvation throughout wholesome Scripture. How the boa constrictor of Calvin’s rigorously novel theory of penal substitution could have strangled the Pauline proclamation of God’s resurrectionary justice toward the Lord Jesus can perhaps only be accounted for by the power of the sinful fleshly impulse toward personal avenging in combination with steady steps of systematic rationalizations that undermined sound exegetical treatments of key passages, all while cross-wiring them in new patterns that were both more amenable to fleshly dispositions of mind, less challenging to faith in a God of miracles, less demanding of obedience to the directives of the Lord Jesus, and less inclined to the example of his obedience to the death of a cross. Jesus became a weak substitute rather than a mighty Lord and a commanding Leader. [6/8/11;5/17/24]
God’s surrender of His Son, the Lord Jesus Christ, was not as a payment of our human debt of sin; if anything, IT ENORMOUSLY AGGRAVATED THE DEBT! IT SWELLED THE SIN OF ISRAEL TO THE BURSTING POINT! If there was any possible hope for Israel to make payment for her many sins (especially of slaying the prophets), by her own righteous deeds, it was utterly BANKRUPTED and totally demolished by the summum malum of CRUCIFYING JESUS! This was not a “deposit” into their “heavenly account” but a massive OVERDRAFT!
The direct implication of this stark fact is that God’s plan for the salvation of Israel, indeed, of all humankind, entailed and demanded THE MOST PATENTLY OBVIOUS DEBT FORGIVENESS EVER UNDERTAKEN IN HISTORY! (And we, in turn, are to forgive as our heavenly Father has thus forgiven us!) The Cross was the last straw; so little did this crime “pay off” God’s penal justice for any human sins (whether of “the elect” or the whole world) that, to the contrary, it greatly compounded human sin, yet happily evoked God’s own personal REPAYMENT to Jesus for his colossal loss. This is the astonishing way the Gospel actually works, contrary to the longstanding but novel traditions of the ‘magisterial’ Protestant Reformation. [6/8/11; 5/17/24]
Penal substitution THROWS STUMBLING BLOCKS AND SNARES BEFORE PEOPLE, thus injuring faith and the credibility of the Message about Jesus Christ. In particular, it is subversive of the character of God the Father. It perversely rationalizes the Atonement according to a strictly penal model that is inherently and irremediably offensive. With excruciating irony, the penal satisfaction accounting of the assassination of God the Son amounts to a character assassination of God the Father, unintentional though it always appears to be. [6/10/11; 5/17/24]
“GOD IS IMPOSSIBLE TO SATISFY, BUT EASY TO PLEASE.” — George MacDonald, quoted in Jan Karon, In the Company of Others (New York: J. P. Putnam’s Sons, 2010).